Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and His Passion for Rugby

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was born in Edinburgh in 1859, and went on to study medicine at Edinburgh University. It is here that he met an eccentric professor who inspired the invention of one of the best loved literary characters in history – Sherlock Holmes. With four novels and 56 short stories detailing the adventures of the sleuth, Mr Holmes has become embedded in British culture and has made 292 screen appearances to date – experiencing a surge in popularity in recent times with the BBC’s award-winning sensation Sherlock, starring heartthrob Benedict Cumberbatch. However, having strayed somewhat far from the original stories with endless modernisations, it is interesting to now revisit the tales and uncover Conan Doyle’s frequent and unmissable references to sport – and in particular, the game of rugby.

Conan Doyle was a keen sportsman and an impressive all-rounder: he played on occasion for the Portsmouth Association Football Club and the Marybelone Cricket Club, as well as being an amateur boxer and golfer. His rugby career began as a teenager, though he complained that his school played a ‘hybrid game peculiar to the place’, and continued at university where he played on the Edinburgh Medical School rugby team. His aptitude for rugby was not quite what it was for football or for cricket, but rugby was closest to his heart, and he travelled the world to see matches in France, South Africa and New Zealand. He wrote in his 1924 autobiography that, on balance, he regarded rugby as the ‘best collective sport’, requiring the greatest skill both physically and mentally. Despite taking time out to pursue athletic hobbies, his sporting interests were not entirely separate from his literary endeavours. One Sherlock Holmes story in particular – The Adventures of the Missing Three-Quarter, published in 1904 – revolves entirely around a game of rugby.

The story begins with a Mr Cyril Overton seeking Holmes’s help, after one of his key players on the Cambridge University rugby union team – Godfrey Staunton (a three-quarter, as the title suggests) – has mysteriously disappeared. If he is not found by the morning Cambridge are sure to lose their match against Oxford the following day, so speed is of the essence. Holmes and Watson discover that Staunton has been in touch with a doctor, and with the help of Foxhound Pompey, track the doctor’s carriage to a country cottage. Here they discover Staunton with his wife, who has just died of consumption; the marriage had had to remain a secret because Staunton’s cruel uncle would not have approved of the match and his nephew would henceforth be disinherited. Thus he told no one of his whereabouts when he was informed that his wife had fallen ill. This rather tragic tale was likely to have been inspired by Conan Doyle’s own experiences: his first wife Louisa Hawkins fell ill with consumption around the time that the story was written, and died two years after its publication. The Adventures of the Missing Three-Quarter has been adapted for both television and radio, but remains relatively unknown amongst the Holmes stories. However, Sydney Paget provided some exquisite illustrations to accompany it, including an amusing sketch of Holmes, Watson and the foxhound stalking the doctor’s carriage to Staunton’s location.

Other references to the sport in his writing include a chapter dedicated to commentating a rugby match in The Firm of Girdlestone (1890) and the revelation in The Adventure of the Sussex Vampire (1924) that Watson once played on the wing for Blackheath – a highly prestigious rugby team. Thus, it would appear that rugby was always present in the writer’s subconscious, and he could not resist a mention here and there.

Conan Doyle died of a heart attack in 1930 at the age of 71, having fathered five children, and is buried with his second wife Jean Leckie in Hampshire, to whom he was touchingly devoted. His last words, “You are wonderful”, are said to have directed at Jean, despite her lack of interest in rugby! He was a man of many passions, but it is not often acknowledged that the game held such a special place in his heart.

About the Author – Cecilia Neil-Smith is reading Victorian Literature, Art and Culture at Royal Holloway, University of London. She has been part of the World Rugby Museum team since 2019.

Visit our website and follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Buy Twickenham Stadium Tour and World Rugby Museum gift vouchers.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and His Passion for Rugby

  1. rhymboy1 says:

    Cecilia, Our Rugby Memorabilia Society member Dick Tyson is something of an expert in this field: Worth a word? Phil Atkinson


  2. Richard Steele says:

    A most enjoyable foray into rugby in fiction – thanks


  3. rhymboy1 says:

    and only one i in dicky too!


  4. keithgregson says:

    All new to me and a great read. I am pretty sure ( although in lock down not certain as to the operation of my brain) that ACD was an athletics’ umpire and was involved in an (Olympic???) incident where he was one of the people who helped an exhausted distance runner across the line – a cause of much controversy. I can visualise the photograph of the event in my mind. Am I right?


    • Richard Steele says:

      You are right, Keith, in that Arthur Conan Doyle did witness at close hand the spectacular ending of the Marathon at the Olympic Games at White City on 24 July 1908. The Italian runner Dorando Petri collapsed short of the line and had to be helped across by the race clerk and the medical officer. A very famous photo of the occasion is regularly posted. As a result Dorando was disqualified and always said that he had been robbed of his Olympic medal!

      So ACD was not an umpire but, fascinatingly for us rugby researchers, the portly medical officer who helped him across the line was an ex-Irish rugby international. Dr Michael Joseph Bulger won one cap for Ireland as a three-quarter against the New Zealand Maoris in December 1888. His younger brother LQ ‘Larry’ Bulger was a strong winger and an excellent kicker who played eight times for Ireland between 1896 and 1898, scoring two tries and 22 points. He also toured South Africa with the British isles in 1896, playing in all four tests and scoring a try in the opening test at Port Elizabeth.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s